1099 or W-2? Understanding the IRS’s 20-Point Checklist for Home Care Business Owners

One of the biggest decisions home care business owners face is whether to classify their caregivers as independent contractors (1099) or employees (W-2). This choice carries serious financial, legal, and operational consequences. Misclassification can lead to IRS penalties, back taxes, and even lawsuits.

The IRS uses a 20-point checklist to determine whether a worker should be classified as an independent contractor or an employee. Understanding this checklist is essential for home care business owners who want to stay compliant and avoid costly mistakes.

Understanding the 1099 vs. W-2 Debate

Before we dive into the IRS checklist, let’s define the two classifications:

• 1099 Independent Contractors: These caregivers operate as self-employed professionals responsible for their taxes, training, and tools. They typically have more control over their schedules and work for multiple clients or agencies.

• W-2 Employees: These caregivers are directly employed by your agency, meaning you control their schedule, provide training, and withhold payroll taxes. Employees are also covered by workers' compensation and other employer benefits.

Many home care business owners assume that classifying caregivers as 1099s saves money, but improper classification can lead to serious legal consequences.

IRS’s 20-Point Checklist: What It Means for Home Care Businesses

The IRS uses a 20-factor test (now streamlined into three main categories: Behavioral Control, Financial Control, and Relationship of the Parties) to determine classification. Here are some key points from the checklist that directly impact home care agencies:

1. Behavioral Control (How much control do you have over the caregiver?)

• Do you provide training to caregivers? (If yes, they are likely employees.)

• Do you dictate the caregiver’s schedule and assignments? (If yes, they are likely employees.)

• Do you require caregivers to follow specific procedures? (If yes, they are likely employees.)

Example: Home Care Agencies that are Medicaid providers must follow strict guidelines. The client's specific care plan and schedule are determined by the agency, not the caregiver. This level of control means that the caregiver is legally classified as a W-2 employee, even if the agency initially intended to hire them as a 1099 contractor.

2. Financial Control (Who controls the caregiver's business aspects?)

• Do caregivers supply their own tools (e.g., uniforms, gloves, PPE)? (If no, they are likely employees.)

• Are caregivers reimbursed for expenses? (If yes, they are likely employees.)

• Can caregivers work for other agencies freely? (If no, they are likely employees.)

3. Relationship of the Parties (How does your contract define the relationship?)

• Is the caregiver receiving benefits like health insurance or retirement plans? (If yes, they are likely employees.)

• Is the relationship ongoing rather than project-based? (If yes, they are likely employees.)

• Does the caregiver sign a non-compete or exclusivity agreement? (If yes, they are likely employees.)

Which Option is Best for Your Home Care Business?

While hiring caregivers as 1099 independent contractors might seem like a cost-saving strategy, it comes with risks: ✅ Less administrative burden ✅ No payroll taxes or benefits to cover ❌ IRS audits & penalties if misclassified ❌ Risk of labor law violations

On the other hand, hiring W-2 employees means: ✅ More control over caregiver performance ✅ Compliance with state labor laws ✅ Access to government contracts and Medicaid programs ❌ Higher costs due to payroll taxes & benefits

Real-World Case Studies: Lessons from Misclassified Home Care Agencies

Many home care agencies have faced significant penalties for misclassifying their workers. Here are two notable cases:

🔹 Case Study #1: Large Home Care Agency Faces Multi-Million Dollar Fines A well-known home care provider in California classified its caregivers as 1099 contractors to reduce payroll costs. However, the state labor board determined that the company exercised too much control over the caregivers’ schedules, training, and client assignments. As a result, the agency was fined over $5 million in back taxes, unpaid overtime, and penalties.

🔹 Case Study #2: Small Home Care Business Hit with IRS Audit A small agency in Florida initially hired caregivers as independent contractors. The IRS audited the agency after several caregivers filed complaints about lack of benefits and unpaid overtime. The IRS ruled that the caregivers were misclassified and required the agency to pay $250,000 in back wages and tax penalties. The financial burden nearly forced the agency to close.

These cases highlight that misclassification occurs more frequently with unlicensed staff (such as home health aides and personal care assistants) compared to licensed professionals like Registered Nurses (RNs) and Therapists, who often have more autonomy in their work.

As a home care business owner, it is critical to carefully assess how you classify your caregivers. Misclassifying workers can result in fines, back taxes, and legal issues that can damage your business.

🔹 Review your hiring model and contracts. Ensure they align with IRS guidelines. 🔹 Consult with an accountant or employment attorney. Get expert advice before making a decision. 🔹 Stay updated on state and federal labor laws. Some states have stricter rules on worker classification.

Want to make sure your home care agency is structured correctly? Join my mentorship program to get guidance on compliance, hiring, and business growth!